FOI26/27 158 Question by Question marks for each candidate at Vale of Leven Academy

Date published: 20/11/2026

FOI reference: 26/27 158

Date received: 11/09/2026

Date responded: 09/10/2026

Information requested

Dear Freedom of Information Officer, Under the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002, please provide the following information for all students presented by Vale of Leven Academy in every subject and at every qualification level offered by the school from 2022 to 2026 inclusive. For each subject and qualification level, please provide:

The marks awarded for every individual question and sub-question for every student in each externally marked examination or assessment.

The marks awarded for each assignment, project, practical activity, portfolio or other externally assessed coursework component for every student.

The total marks awarded for each examination paper and coursework component.

The overall mark or total used to determine each candidate?s result.

The relevant examination year, subject, qualification level and course code.

The number of students represented in each set of results.
Please provide this information for all available examination years and include every student presented by the school. The information should be anonymised, with each student represented by a unique identifier so that their question-level and component-level marks can be followed within the relevant course without revealing their identity. Please supply the information electronically, preferably as a CSV or Excel spreadsheet, with separate fields for:

Examination year

School or centre

Subject and course code

Qualification level

Anonymised student identifier

Assessment component or paper

Question and sub-question

Maximum available mark

Mark awarded

Coursework or assignment mark

Overall course mark.

If student-level information cannot be disclosed because of the risk of identification, please provide the information in the most detailed aggregated form possible, including the number of candidates receiving each mark for every question and sub-question. If fulfilling the request for all available years would exceed the statutory cost limit, please provide the information for the most recent five examination years. Please also offer advice and assistance on how the request could be narrowed while retaining the greatest possible level of detail. If any information is withheld, please identify the applicable exemption, explain why it applies and provide all remaining information that can be disclosed. If Qualifications Scotland does not hold any part of the requested information, please identify which information is not held and, where known, advise whether it is held by Vale of Leven Academy, West Dunbartonshire Council or another public authority.

Response

We are unable to provide the information requested as it is considered exempt under section 38(1)(b) of the Freedom of Information (Scotland) Act 2002 (“FOISA”), as the information requested constitutes personal data relating to individual candidates.

Your request seeks the mark achieved by each candidate for each examination question, sub-question and assessment, broken down by subject, in relation to Vale of Leven Academy. This is information about the examination performance of individual candidates. 

We have considered whether the information could be anonymised before disclosure. We have concluded that effective anonymisation would not be possible while retaining the level of detail requested.

The information relates to a relatively small population of candidates at a named school. The request would then further divide that population by subject and by individual examination question, sub-question and assessment. Consequently, the number of candidates represented within individual categories may be very small and, in some instances, the information would relate to only one or a very small number of candidates. This means that there is a risk of identification.

The risk of identification does not arise solely from the size of the cohort. It arises from the combination of the relatively small population, the detailed nature of the information requested and other information that may reasonably be known or available to persons familiar with the school and its candidates.

A further consideration is the information already held by the school. Qualifications Scotland provides every school with information on Grades, Grade Bands and Component Marks for every learner in their school. The information held by the school can be used to link individual pupils to their subjects, grades and marks for the relevant examination papers. The requested information would provide candidate-level marks for individual questions, sub-questions and assessments.

Although the information disclosed under FOISA would not necessarily include the names of candidates, the combination of the detailed question-level marks with information already known or reasonably available to persons familiar with the school could enable individual candidates to be identified.

For example, where a candidate's subject, grade and overall paper mark are known, the detailed question-level marks disclosed could potentially be used to match that candidate to a particular set of results. The more detailed the information disclosed, the more distinctive an individual candidate's pattern of marks may become and the greater the potential for matching that information with other information.

This is therefore not simply a case of a small number of candidates making identification theoretically possible. There is a potential means of linking the disclosed information to individual candidates using existing information about candidates' subjects, grades and examination performance. We consider that this creates a realistic prospect of individual candidates being identified.

The fact that you are associated with the school is also relevant to our assessment, as such an association may provide knowledge of the school, its candidates, the subjects they study and other information that could assist in linking disclosed results to particular individuals. We have nevertheless assessed the risk in the context of disclosure to the public generally, rather than relying solely on the circumstances or intentions of the individual requester.

Assigning a unique identifier to each candidate would not, in our view, resolve this issue. Replacing a candidate's name with a unique identifier would constitute pseudonymisation rather than effective anonymisation if the candidate could subsequently be identified by combining the disclosed marks with other information. The detailed pattern of marks for an individual candidate could itself provide a means of identifying that candidate.

It should also be noted that disclosure under FOISA is disclosure to the public generally and not solely to the requester. We must therefore consider whether the information could be disclosed without creating a realistic prospect of individual candidates being identified by persons who have, or can reasonably obtain, other relevant information.

We have considered Decision 098/2019 of the Scottish Information Commissioner, which concerned examination results for a named school. In that decision, the Commissioner accepted that a relatively small population, further broken down by subject and grade, created a realistic prospect of individual pupils being identified. The Commissioner also recognised that information known to third parties, including knowledge of the subjects studied by individual pupils, could increase the likelihood of identification.

We consider that the circumstances of your request create an even greater identification risk. Decision 098/2019 concerned aggregate numbers of pupils achieving particular grades. In contrast, this request seeks the marks achieved by individual candidates for individual examination questions, sub-questions and assessments. The information is therefore considerably more detailed and is directly connected to the examination performance of individual candidates. Decision 098/2019 can be accessed using the following link:

Decision098-2019.pdf

Having considered the nature of the information, the size of the population, the level of detail requested and information that may reasonably be available to third parties, we consider that there is a realistic prospect that individual candidates could be identified. The information therefore constitutes personal data for the purposes of section 38(1)(b) of FOISA.

We have considered whether disclosure of this personal data would be lawful under Article 6 of the UK GDPR.

We accept that schools have a legitimate interest in obtaining information about the performance of the school. We recognise that the requested information would allow you to undertake a detailed analysis of performance.

We have nevertheless considered whether disclosure of the candidates' personal data is necessary to meet that legitimate interest and whether that interest can be met by less intrusive means. In addition to the information already available to the school, you can access the average and mean marks for the Vale of Leven Academy through our statistical app available on our website via this link Attainment and Item Mean Marks by Centre. This provides access to information about overall performance for all schools without disclosing individual candidates' marks.

We have therefore considered that there are alternative means of obtaining information about the school's overall performance without disclosing personal data relating to individual candidates.

We have also considered whether, notwithstanding the availability of these alternative means, your legitimate interest would outweigh the interests, fundamental rights and freedoms of the candidates concerned.

In carrying out this balancing exercise, we have given particular consideration to the fact that the information relates to children and concerns their individual examination performance.

Documents: